Home Baked Pies

We expect a heavy volume of orders again, and may not have a selection for you to choose from if you do not order ahead. It is unlikely that we will have extra pies in the shop. We cannot guarantee orders placed after Saturday, December 16.

Pie Ordering for holidays:

For Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter we will have order forms available online and in the store weeks ahead.  It is very important to respect the deadlines on the order forms for these holidays.

Download Holiday Pie Form

All fruit flavors are made with either a regular or crumb crust.  Most pies are available sugar-free and all flavors are available in a 4-inch size with 24 hours notice.  If you would like a specific pie flavor, please be sure to call at least 24 hours in advance to ensure we have time to fill your order!

Smith's Orchard Bake Shop Flavors

  • Apple
  • Apple Blackberry
  • Apple Blueberry
  • Apple Cherry
  • Apple Cranberry
  • Apple Cranberry Walnut
  • Apple Peach
  • Apple Raisin Walnut
  • Apple Raspberry
  • Blackberry
  • Blueberry
  • Blueberry Peach
  • Cherry
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie
  • Mince *SEASONAL
  • Peach
  • Pecan
  • Pineapple
  • Pumpkin
  • Raspberry
  • Raspberry Peach
  • Raspberry Rhubarb
  • Rhubarb
  • Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Tollhouse
  • Very Berry
  • Pumpkin Pecan *SEASONAL
  • Rum Fudge Pecan *SEASONAL

Pie Availability:

In general, we try to have a good variety of pies available for sale at all times.  However, if you wish to come in and purchase a specific flavor it is best to guarantee availability by calling us at least 24 hours in advance to place an order.

Need a pie in a hurry and can’t make it out to the pie shop in Charlton?

Check out our list of stores that carry our pies to find a place near you!

  • Primal your Local Butcher Wilton and Stuyvesant Plaza (the Clifton Park store closed)
  • Fred the Butcher Halfmoon NY
  • Fred the Butcher 2 Slingerlands, NY
  • Town & Country Deli Amsterdam NY
  • Karen’s Garden Tribes Hill (seasonal)
  • Garden Bug Amsterdam NY (seasonal)
  • Apple Barrel Schoharie, NY
  • Locust Grove Farm, Argyle NY
  • Kleinke’s Farm Glenmont NY (seasonal)
  • Hill’s Discount Beverage Broadalbin NY
  • Mayfield Plaza, Mayfield NY
  • Fullers Corner Store Edinburg NY
  • J. F Farm store & cafe Northville NY
  • Glenville Farm, Glenville NY (seasonal)
  • Kings Dairy Schuylerville NY
Scroll to Top